By and large, I've never given much thought to other photographers and the work they're doing, because I'm doing my own work and it stands on its own merits. By and large though, my reason for feeling that way is because I don't tend to encounter that many other photographers - which means I don't have to confront my own insecurities about my abilities...
Today I visited somewhere I'll be doing some shoots in the coming weeks. It's a big job that I'm looking forward to - the location is fantastic and I know I'll meet some great people there. When I was being shown around though, I was introduced to another photographer, who was doing some work on-site. Nothing like what I was doing - just some staff portraits - but it stopped me in my tracks for a minute...
The staff portraits were good - they were lit with natural light, but what's noteworthy was that to get an even exposure, he was using a Lastolite reflector to bounce light back, so it hit both sides of the subject's face. So why did it stop me in my tracks...?
Whenever I'm on a job, I meet a lot of people who tell me their boyfriend/girlfriend/sister/friend is a photographer - a lot. Sometimes I'll ask for their details so I can look them up, but invariably (99 times out of 100) they're not making a living from photography, they just either have a half-decent camera, or they spend a lot of time uploading pictures to Flickr.
But no - in this case, the reflector showed that they'd thought things through - they'd thought about the light - they actually were a photographer...
My insecurity instantly makes me think - well this guy's clearly got a foot in the door - what's to say he doesn't get asked to do the photos I'm looking to do instead of me?
It was stupid I know... I don't know what this person's work is like, what their speciality is, even whether they're looking to do work like I'm doing. When it comes down to it as well, I know that I'm the one who came up with the idea for the work, and I have my own style and my own thoughts about the execution of the work...
At the end of the day, it's just a matter of insecurity and a lack of self-esteem - a trait I really don't mind admitting to. It comes with knowing that, while I have a very specific style, and I see light in a way that not so many fellow photographers seem to be able to, a lot of my work isn't down to a Photoshop technique that sets me apart from other people, or because my photos are processed in a way nobody else can - it's because of human relations - and to me, I don't know how much of that is something unique to me, or whether other people can get the same results - can someone who has, or is given, the same brief as me, end up with the same photos, or work that's better?
The insecurity I suppose comes from looking at my work pretty much all day, every day. It's become ordinary to me, and so I end up feeling like anyone can take the shots I can. In the end, I don't want to be the 'jobbing photographer' I've talked about in other posts - whose work just disappears into the background, doing the kind of work that's the equivalent of a session musician - something that could have been done by anyone, and only you know it's there. I guess the moral of the story is to push yourself, and to make sure you get the opportunities that the other people don't, but also to set yourself apart - in every aspect of your work - whether technique, approach or otherwise - to make sure you can always look at your work and feel proud of what you're doing.
Showing posts with label Photoshop. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Photoshop. Show all posts
Wednesday, 27 June 2012
Sunday, 8 April 2012
The (Colour) Space Between Us...
The title's just the name of one of my favourite Zero 7 songs - nothing to do with the post, but I thought it was a little clever - check me out...
I mentioned in an earlier post that I'd decided to pick up a copy of Photoshop for the Mac, as opposed to working with my decrepit copy of CS2 on my PC. A look at my book last week encouraged me to take a fresh look at my colour management though, as there seemed to be some issues.
I get most of my work printed at theprintspace. They're friendly, do a very quick turnaround and include lots of helpful information on their website on colour profiling - fantastic if, like me, you want to make sure your prints are as close to what you see in your mind's eye as is possible.
Just recently though I've had a few images through that had either a bit of a cyan or magenta cast to them, and was wondering where this was coming from. I was working on my PC using a monitor calibrated with an i1 Display and I'd downloaded their ICC profiles to ensure my working colour profile was as close to their printers as possible. It just didn't make sense. I decided to check out the images I'd had printed on my Mac to see if there was a difference in the profiles.
I was actually pretty surprised...
Have a look at the image on the right - it's my Mac on the left and my PC on the right. Both in Adobe RGB. The Mac is running Photoshop CS5 and the PC is running CS2, but they've been calibrated using the same calibration tool a matter of days apart. The image on the PC looks much more natural, because that's basically how I wanted the shot to look when I edited it on the PC, but the image on the Mac screen is exactly the same image, just open on a different machine.
It's pretty scary...
The image on the Mac looks like it has a cyan/green cast to it - and it does. You could be mistaken for thinking that the Mac's the machine that's not calibrated properly, but given the images I'm getting back from the printer, it's actually the one that's most accurate. The PC screen, though you can't really see it here, has more of a yellow cast to it, making the shots look much warmer, but put them on another monitor and they look very different. As I've essentially been overcompensating for a particular colour cast, I've actually ended up introducing another with my corrections.
Print them out and the shots aren't too offensive - it's just you end up with a cyan cast and a much cooler image, but that doesn't suit a shot where my subject is pouring bright yellow lemon curd into jars - it's supposed to look warm, and the print image just doesn't look that way - it actually looks cold...
I decided to give it another go - like I've done with other shots that I've revisited to see if I can bring them out more, I gave this shot another go, now with Photoshop CS5 on what seems to be a better calibrated monitor, and ended up with this on the left... It feels much more natural to me - and much warmer too. It was edited using theprintspace's ICC profile for Fuji Gloss, and while it could do with a little more work (there's a little bit of a green cast, and I'd like to bring the reds down a little) it's nowhere near as 'cool' as the previous version.
Oh - and open the images by clicking on them. For some reason the smaller thumbnails render differently from how they look when they're open - the first image looks more red, while the other actually looks quite neutral. Open the second and you'll see that the second image looks almost drained of colour.
It's annoying when things like this happen - as far as I'm concerned if you calibrate your monitor using the same device, both monitors should look exactly the same, but this is clearly not the case here.

So it's difficult to know exactly what you're going to end up with - I was sat there at my PC thinking that I was editing an image that would be perfect when printed, but loading it on a different computer using a different monitor, you can see just how much difference there can be. Maybe when it comes down to it, I'm being too picky about things, but then, why spend the time setting up a shot and taking the image, before mastering it in Photoshop afterwards, only to find when it comes to printing that your colour profiles are completely off?
It's crazy - it's not something you can just convert to the new profile on your other computer - you have to start from scratch with the original RAW image. Best to get it right from the start than to have to go back time and time again, while spending a fortune paying for prints that don't look right...
I mentioned in an earlier post that I'd decided to pick up a copy of Photoshop for the Mac, as opposed to working with my decrepit copy of CS2 on my PC. A look at my book last week encouraged me to take a fresh look at my colour management though, as there seemed to be some issues.
I get most of my work printed at theprintspace. They're friendly, do a very quick turnaround and include lots of helpful information on their website on colour profiling - fantastic if, like me, you want to make sure your prints are as close to what you see in your mind's eye as is possible.
Just recently though I've had a few images through that had either a bit of a cyan or magenta cast to them, and was wondering where this was coming from. I was working on my PC using a monitor calibrated with an i1 Display and I'd downloaded their ICC profiles to ensure my working colour profile was as close to their printers as possible. It just didn't make sense. I decided to check out the images I'd had printed on my Mac to see if there was a difference in the profiles.
I was actually pretty surprised...Have a look at the image on the right - it's my Mac on the left and my PC on the right. Both in Adobe RGB. The Mac is running Photoshop CS5 and the PC is running CS2, but they've been calibrated using the same calibration tool a matter of days apart. The image on the PC looks much more natural, because that's basically how I wanted the shot to look when I edited it on the PC, but the image on the Mac screen is exactly the same image, just open on a different machine.
It's pretty scary...
The image on the Mac looks like it has a cyan/green cast to it - and it does. You could be mistaken for thinking that the Mac's the machine that's not calibrated properly, but given the images I'm getting back from the printer, it's actually the one that's most accurate. The PC screen, though you can't really see it here, has more of a yellow cast to it, making the shots look much warmer, but put them on another monitor and they look very different. As I've essentially been overcompensating for a particular colour cast, I've actually ended up introducing another with my corrections.
Print them out and the shots aren't too offensive - it's just you end up with a cyan cast and a much cooler image, but that doesn't suit a shot where my subject is pouring bright yellow lemon curd into jars - it's supposed to look warm, and the print image just doesn't look that way - it actually looks cold...
I decided to give it another go - like I've done with other shots that I've revisited to see if I can bring them out more, I gave this shot another go, now with Photoshop CS5 on what seems to be a better calibrated monitor, and ended up with this on the left... It feels much more natural to me - and much warmer too. It was edited using theprintspace's ICC profile for Fuji Gloss, and while it could do with a little more work (there's a little bit of a green cast, and I'd like to bring the reds down a little) it's nowhere near as 'cool' as the previous version.
Oh - and open the images by clicking on them. For some reason the smaller thumbnails render differently from how they look when they're open - the first image looks more red, while the other actually looks quite neutral. Open the second and you'll see that the second image looks almost drained of colour.
It's annoying when things like this happen - as far as I'm concerned if you calibrate your monitor using the same device, both monitors should look exactly the same, but this is clearly not the case here.

So it's difficult to know exactly what you're going to end up with - I was sat there at my PC thinking that I was editing an image that would be perfect when printed, but loading it on a different computer using a different monitor, you can see just how much difference there can be. Maybe when it comes down to it, I'm being too picky about things, but then, why spend the time setting up a shot and taking the image, before mastering it in Photoshop afterwards, only to find when it comes to printing that your colour profiles are completely off?
It's crazy - it's not something you can just convert to the new profile on your other computer - you have to start from scratch with the original RAW image. Best to get it right from the start than to have to go back time and time again, while spending a fortune paying for prints that don't look right...
Labels:
Adobe RGB,
Client,
Colour,
Colour Profile,
Colour Space,
CS2,
CS5,
Curd,
Cyan,
Macbook Pro,
Naked Jam,
PC,
Photoshop,
Print,
theprintspace,
Yellow
Friday, 23 March 2012
Graphic Design...
For ages now, I've been putting off buying Photoshop for my MacBook Pro. I have a PC and I have a MacBook Pro, but while the Mac is the obvious choice to be running Photoshop, the PC has had Photoshop for years because of friends in the industry who use PCs who have been able to flow me a copy. The trouble has always been that my PC is seven years old and just isn't capable of handling huge TIFF files, or even the most basic layers. Open a file from Lightroom and more often than not, it can take around 5-10 minutes to open, with as much time sometimes taken to make even the slightest adjustments. I'm sure you can imagine that hardly makes for stress-free editing...
After a job last week where there was a lot of post-processing, I decided I had to do it, regardless of the cost. That, and the fact that there are features in CS5 that are much more effective than the ones in my ancient copy of CS2.
So I've spent some of today re-learning Photoshop, because trust me, in CS5 there are features that are totally new and are bound to take a fair bit of getting used to...
Or not...
You see, I'm not afraid of technology in any respect, but I am fairly traditional in my photography, and my overall feeling is that if you're a photographer, that's what you should be. There are so many tools in Photoshop that seem to me to be applications for correcting what you should have gotten right 'in camera' that I wonder what we're becoming? I see videos on YouTube about the remarkable new features of the new Photoshop and how they'll help in your editing and retouching, but you see all the time these people are airbrushing, cloning, healing... Surely these are things a good photographer shouldn't be carrying over into their post-processing, but should in fact take the kind of shot that means there are no significant adjustments to be made - at least none that require hours spent in front of your monitor...?
I'm a photographer, not a graphic designer... These are good tools to have if the job demands it - and last week's job, where I had to edit out a copyrighted image from a piece of clothing certainly called for that - but all these tools, when used to change and image from what it originally was...? That doesn't sit right with me...
After a job last week where there was a lot of post-processing, I decided I had to do it, regardless of the cost. That, and the fact that there are features in CS5 that are much more effective than the ones in my ancient copy of CS2.
So I've spent some of today re-learning Photoshop, because trust me, in CS5 there are features that are totally new and are bound to take a fair bit of getting used to...
Or not...
You see, I'm not afraid of technology in any respect, but I am fairly traditional in my photography, and my overall feeling is that if you're a photographer, that's what you should be. There are so many tools in Photoshop that seem to me to be applications for correcting what you should have gotten right 'in camera' that I wonder what we're becoming? I see videos on YouTube about the remarkable new features of the new Photoshop and how they'll help in your editing and retouching, but you see all the time these people are airbrushing, cloning, healing... Surely these are things a good photographer shouldn't be carrying over into their post-processing, but should in fact take the kind of shot that means there are no significant adjustments to be made - at least none that require hours spent in front of your monitor...?
I'm a photographer, not a graphic designer... These are good tools to have if the job demands it - and last week's job, where I had to edit out a copyrighted image from a piece of clothing certainly called for that - but all these tools, when used to change and image from what it originally was...? That doesn't sit right with me...
Labels:
Airbrush,
Cloning,
CS5,
Editing,
Features,
Macbook Pro,
PC,
Photoshop,
Processing,
Technology
Monday, 28 November 2011
On the Bright Side...
My photos are darker than most. It's intentional... You'll rarely catch me taking a shot that's bright and breezy, or full of natural bright light... I don't always know why that is - it just seems that I'm drawn to shadow, and I love contrast...
I do sometimes wonder if that's what puts people off sometimes though - my work has been referred to at times as 'moody' or 'atmospheric', and granted, these have been for theatre jobs where the production has been dark and moody, but then I do get the feeling that the whole 'moody' thing was a diplomatic way of saying my shots are too dark.
On Saturday I put in an order for another batch of business cards from moo.com, and the diplomacy came up again when it came to uploading shots to go on the reverse side of the cards...
What you're looking at above is a screengrab from the image upload page. You basically upload your shots so you can preview them before ordering. What moo do though, is automatically (politely...?) optimise your images so - by their standards - they're being presented in the best light. It can be annoying - especially when as a photographer you feel the shots you're uploading are as they're supposed to be, and it's especially frustrating when you're uploading your shots to an actual printing website - I understand that some people don't have Photoshop or Lightroom, and so they don't have the tools to adjust their images, but at the same time, I don't generally appreciate having my images adjusted for me.
You can switch it off, as I did, but it has made me ask the question of whether my images, while dark, are too dark...
When printed, my shots pretty much always look how I want them to look - the contrast, the tones, the colours... After all, I didn't spend a fortune on getting a colour profiler if I didn't want to be as certain as I could be that the images on my screen were as close to what was going to be printed, or what I wanted to appear on my portfolio.
For reference, the original version of the image you see above is here on the right - and you can see that it is much darker - there are more shadows and there's more contrast. I actually like that, but is it what the client wants? Looking at it, I still prefer my version - I feel there's more depth to it, and it's not at the expense of the detail either. You can see the subject's face and eyes, and you can make out everything in the shot - you're not left straining to work out what you're looking at. The whites are white, not grey, and the background doesn't intrude into the shot.
It's not difficult to end up with the shot above - I always underexpose by one stop, so I have some exposure latitude to work with. By removing that, and not using contrast in Photoshop when it comes to the editing of the image, I would have an image as bright as the one you see above - but then looking at it, would it be a shot you can identify as being one of my shots, or would it be just another shot, like any other you might see in a magazine or newspaper...?
I'd love to know what anyone else thinks...
I do sometimes wonder if that's what puts people off sometimes though - my work has been referred to at times as 'moody' or 'atmospheric', and granted, these have been for theatre jobs where the production has been dark and moody, but then I do get the feeling that the whole 'moody' thing was a diplomatic way of saying my shots are too dark.
On Saturday I put in an order for another batch of business cards from moo.com, and the diplomacy came up again when it came to uploading shots to go on the reverse side of the cards...
What you're looking at above is a screengrab from the image upload page. You basically upload your shots so you can preview them before ordering. What moo do though, is automatically (politely...?) optimise your images so - by their standards - they're being presented in the best light. It can be annoying - especially when as a photographer you feel the shots you're uploading are as they're supposed to be, and it's especially frustrating when you're uploading your shots to an actual printing website - I understand that some people don't have Photoshop or Lightroom, and so they don't have the tools to adjust their images, but at the same time, I don't generally appreciate having my images adjusted for me.
You can switch it off, as I did, but it has made me ask the question of whether my images, while dark, are too dark...
When printed, my shots pretty much always look how I want them to look - the contrast, the tones, the colours... After all, I didn't spend a fortune on getting a colour profiler if I didn't want to be as certain as I could be that the images on my screen were as close to what was going to be printed, or what I wanted to appear on my portfolio.
For reference, the original version of the image you see above is here on the right - and you can see that it is much darker - there are more shadows and there's more contrast. I actually like that, but is it what the client wants? Looking at it, I still prefer my version - I feel there's more depth to it, and it's not at the expense of the detail either. You can see the subject's face and eyes, and you can make out everything in the shot - you're not left straining to work out what you're looking at. The whites are white, not grey, and the background doesn't intrude into the shot.It's not difficult to end up with the shot above - I always underexpose by one stop, so I have some exposure latitude to work with. By removing that, and not using contrast in Photoshop when it comes to the editing of the image, I would have an image as bright as the one you see above - but then looking at it, would it be a shot you can identify as being one of my shots, or would it be just another shot, like any other you might see in a magazine or newspaper...?
I'd love to know what anyone else thinks...
Labels:
Atmospheric,
Brightness,
Business Cards,
Colour,
Contrast,
Dark,
Diplomatic,
Light,
moo.com,
Moody,
Optimise,
Photo,
Photoshop,
Profiler
Tuesday, 15 November 2011
What do you really want...?
![]() |
| Image Credit: A&M/Rosie Hardy |
Let's be honest - who wouldn't want their dream assignment flying into their inbox out of nowhere - that little feeling that life will never be the same again and you've really made it...? Congratulations to Rosie - she's experienced something so few people ever will in their lifetime.
For most photographers it doesn't work like that though - it takes years of hard work and experience - not to mention experimentation - and I've barely started on that journey, and so I can hardly comment - and I don't doubt I have years of hardship still to come before I'm even getting close to realising my dream. I can dream of that big break, but in the meantime...
As my career changes and grows with every job that comes my way, I'm thinking about the direction I want to take my work. I don't expect an e-mail to arrive in my inbox anytime soon from National Geographic, but if I do want to shoot for them at some point in my career, so what am I going to do to get there...?
It's something I found when I was doing a desk job - I got into a very specialised area of work, and the further I climbed the career ladder, the harder I found it to move into other areas of work. I had transferable skills of course, but I didn't have the knowledge or the experience to be able to move into other areas. Luckily in terms of the desk job, I didn't want to be doing anything else, but when you think about it, there was a point in that former life where I was taking steps that made it increasingly difficult to move into other areas if I'd wanted to.
I've said in other posts that I try not to define myself as a particular 'genre' of photographer, lest I get pigeon-holed and find it hard to move into other areas - it's the reason I do as much theatre work as I do editorial portraiture, but truth be told, there are certain areas of my work where I am walking down a path where I'm not going to be able to change in future.
An example of this is that I made a promise to myself that other than the basics - that is, colour balance, contrast, levels and sharpening - I wouldn't use Photoshop in my work. That basically means no cloning and no manipulation. One of the things that is very clear about Rosie's work is that she uses a lot of Photoshop. The image for Maroon 5 is a perfect example. Now I'm not going to judge her for that - I get worked up when Photoshop is used to create a false reality that is damaging to people's self-esteem, but in this image it's totally obvious... All the same though, I'm not a graphic designer - I'm a photographer - and it's not my way to manipulate, and I'm not about to change tack, even if it was manipulating images in the obvious way we've seen here. I'm not going to chase a market I have no interest in, so all you're going to get from me are images that are 'real'.
That's going to limit me though - the same as the fact that I'm not going to be chasing after fashion work, or work that I believe is going to objectify women or men. Having morals really does limit your options, and while developing my portfolio to feature that kind of work might boost my earning potential, I'm the kind of person who'll forever feel 'unclean' for having done that kind of work.
So there's my dilemna - I have to make sure I can continue earning a living in the long term by taking photos that don't necessarily appeal from a commercial point of view, or rely on a lot of post-processing work. Is it possible? There's only one way to find out...
Labels:
Aspirations,
Career,
Desk Job,
Direction,
Flickr,
Future,
Manipulation,
Maroon 5,
Obscurity,
Photoshop,
Rosie Hardy
Saturday, 14 May 2011
Fashion...
There are fashions in every industry and every walk of life. I can remember when I worked in local government that there were initiatives that one organisation would pick up, and others would soon follow - it became embarrassing seeing the desperation of those who were "sharing good practice" but were in fact rehashing an approach that would inevitably become a cliché.
It's the same thing in photography of course - you'll see a certain kind of image that in a few weeks or months will be ubiquitous and later hackneyed. I remember when people first started discovering the things you could do in Photoshop, and we were suddenly swamped with images using selective desaturation - the red rose against a black and white background; there were the filters as well - posterise, stained glass, graphic... The list went on... Later, along came HDR and people went crazy for the 3D-like effect they could get
I was never a fan of effects like that - I felt that they were used in an attempt to turn a mediocre photo into something more, where the style outweighed the substance, and if you just scratched below that filter, you'd see that the image was ultimately dull and lifeless, with no specific strengths. I remember being called a snob though for not embracing this 'new technology' and preferring to add impact to my shots with framing, exposure, depth of field and - most importantly - content...

There are fashions in photojournalism as well - and I suppose that's a given. You see an image you like and you try to recreate that, but having seen images like the one above more and more, it kind of makes me wonder just what is driving this - because the continued use of this kind of image as a fallback just makes me feel that either photographers or picture editors are getting lazy.
Granted, it's an effective 'look' - it creates a human interest image that otherwise would be very difficult to achieve - you have the distraught parent or family member holding a picture of a relative, now dead, and the juxtaposition of the sadness and the apparent serenity of the subject of the photo is very powerful, but when you see it in the major newspapers at least a few times a week, it stars to lose that impact.
It sends me back to the times when I'd see people using (and over-using) those Photoshop techniques having seen another photographer's work and feeling like they were simply stealing that person's image - that person's idea, and that they weren't actually creating anything new themselves. It makes you question whether there are any truly new ideas out there, but at the end of the day you've got to ask ourself as well, are you so desperate that you have to bite on someone else's style to get published or paid?
NB: I have tried to find the name of the photographer who took the above image, but so far my search has proved fruitless. If you took it, or know who took it, please leave a comment and I'll be happy to credit or remove as appropriate.
It's the same thing in photography of course - you'll see a certain kind of image that in a few weeks or months will be ubiquitous and later hackneyed. I remember when people first started discovering the things you could do in Photoshop, and we were suddenly swamped with images using selective desaturation - the red rose against a black and white background; there were the filters as well - posterise, stained glass, graphic... The list went on... Later, along came HDR and people went crazy for the 3D-like effect they could get
I was never a fan of effects like that - I felt that they were used in an attempt to turn a mediocre photo into something more, where the style outweighed the substance, and if you just scratched below that filter, you'd see that the image was ultimately dull and lifeless, with no specific strengths. I remember being called a snob though for not embracing this 'new technology' and preferring to add impact to my shots with framing, exposure, depth of field and - most importantly - content...

There are fashions in photojournalism as well - and I suppose that's a given. You see an image you like and you try to recreate that, but having seen images like the one above more and more, it kind of makes me wonder just what is driving this - because the continued use of this kind of image as a fallback just makes me feel that either photographers or picture editors are getting lazy.
Granted, it's an effective 'look' - it creates a human interest image that otherwise would be very difficult to achieve - you have the distraught parent or family member holding a picture of a relative, now dead, and the juxtaposition of the sadness and the apparent serenity of the subject of the photo is very powerful, but when you see it in the major newspapers at least a few times a week, it stars to lose that impact.
It sends me back to the times when I'd see people using (and over-using) those Photoshop techniques having seen another photographer's work and feeling like they were simply stealing that person's image - that person's idea, and that they weren't actually creating anything new themselves. It makes you question whether there are any truly new ideas out there, but at the end of the day you've got to ask ourself as well, are you so desperate that you have to bite on someone else's style to get published or paid?
NB: I have tried to find the name of the photographer who took the above image, but so far my search has proved fruitless. If you took it, or know who took it, please leave a comment and I'll be happy to credit or remove as appropriate.
Labels:
Gimmick,
HDR,
photography,
Photos within Photos,
Photoshop,
Style
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


