I won't delude myself by thinking that anyone reads this, but this can be a useful place to put my thoughts into words...
At the moment, there seems to be a certain amount of debate over one of the finalists of the Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize that I mentioned in my last post. In short, one of the finalists is an uncompromising shot of the photographer's wife, who is naked from the waist down. Don't click the link if you're offended by images of women's genitalia, as it's a particularly graphic image.
Judging from the various reactions I've read, people are generally torn between admiration and disgust - as you'd probably expect. Some talk of an intimate beauty to the shot, while others say it's simply porn dressed up as art.
Where do I stand? Well, my feeling is more one of disappointment than of outright disgust. Some of the images from last year's prize were excellent, both technically and in terms of their subject matter and execution. Last year's winner, Paul Floyd-Blake's portrait of disabled swimmer Rosie Bancroft not only had great impact, but the shot was well lit, well composed, and you felt a connection with the subject.
While Panayiotis Lamprou hasn't won the prize (yet) with his 'Portrait of my British Wife', his inclusion in the shortlist sends out a very strong message - that the panel this year is more concerned with shock and provocation than with excellent portraiture.
I appreciate my opinion is meaningless in the grand scheme of things, but then this is my blog so I can say what I want. Overall, the image for me totally lacks any sort of impact - technically there's no depth to the shot, while the subject's expression speaks nothing of intimacy, and any emotion betrayed on her face is negated by the brashness - the brazenness - of her exposed genitals.
The question I ask is exactly what does the nudity bring to the shot? The pose appears unnatural - I can't think of any woman - any lady - who would display herself in such a manner - unless it's to shock or to provoke a reaction. The shot was set up - there's no doubt about that. I can't see any situation whereby a woman would sit in that way after "sharing an omelette" and I don't know who would have their camera on hand ready to snap that decisive 'moment'.
No - it's a poor photographer who resorts to the cheap trick of flashing his wife's vagina in order to give his shot impact, when there are countless photographers who allow their creativity, their imagination and their technique do the talking. All I see when I look at this shot is a conscious effort to shock, to provoke and to manipulate. The fact that the panel of judges has been taken in by this is a sad reflection on the state of our society today. I can't wait to hear how they're going to justify the inclusion of the shot on their shortlist.
Is it art? No - it's not even photography.
Tuesday, 21 September 2010
Thursday, 16 September 2010
Sour Grapes...
Feel free to ignore this post - I'm just feeling a little raw and bitchy this morning.
You might remember that back at the tail-end of July, I put in some shots for the Taylor-Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize. I didn't hold out any hope of winning it, or even being shortlisted for that matter, but if you don't try then you'll never know.
I found out a few weeks ago that I wasn't successful - no big surprise there - and collected my shots last week. I got a text this morning from a friend saying that he'd seen some of the finalists' shots in the paper and asked if I'd had any luck. I tracked down the shots and to be completely blunt, I wasn't especially impressed. The shots I saw dealt with some interesting themes, but in terms of the style and the execution, I wasn't seeing anything new or exciting.
I buy the British Journal of Photography religiously every month, and often feel intimidated by some of the shots I see in their pages. As a marker for quality and the shape of the market, this is where I go.
But it just goes to show how diverse the market is. That's rather obvious of course, considering the broad areas the term 'photography' covers - be it photojournalism, editorials, weddings, portraits, documentary, commercial or otherwise - but it pays to remember that no matter how 'good' your work might be, there will always be people out there who don't care for it much. Unfortunately some of these people can be in a position of some authority, who can decide whether or not your career progresses in the direction you want it to.
So what are the next steps? Well I can feel bitter and twisted about the fact that my shots weren't shortlisted, or I can just get on with things. I've got an interesting opportunity coming up where the client does like my work (which, of course, is what you want) and I'll look to capitalise on that, rather than feel annoyed or hard done by that I didn't get anywhere in a photo contest. The hard knocks will come and go, but it's churlish to take them personally. I don't like hard rock or techno, but I doubt the people making it care too much about that - they just keep doing what they're doing, because there is a market out there for what you do.
You might remember that back at the tail-end of July, I put in some shots for the Taylor-Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize. I didn't hold out any hope of winning it, or even being shortlisted for that matter, but if you don't try then you'll never know.
I found out a few weeks ago that I wasn't successful - no big surprise there - and collected my shots last week. I got a text this morning from a friend saying that he'd seen some of the finalists' shots in the paper and asked if I'd had any luck. I tracked down the shots and to be completely blunt, I wasn't especially impressed. The shots I saw dealt with some interesting themes, but in terms of the style and the execution, I wasn't seeing anything new or exciting.
I buy the British Journal of Photography religiously every month, and often feel intimidated by some of the shots I see in their pages. As a marker for quality and the shape of the market, this is where I go.
But it just goes to show how diverse the market is. That's rather obvious of course, considering the broad areas the term 'photography' covers - be it photojournalism, editorials, weddings, portraits, documentary, commercial or otherwise - but it pays to remember that no matter how 'good' your work might be, there will always be people out there who don't care for it much. Unfortunately some of these people can be in a position of some authority, who can decide whether or not your career progresses in the direction you want it to.
So what are the next steps? Well I can feel bitter and twisted about the fact that my shots weren't shortlisted, or I can just get on with things. I've got an interesting opportunity coming up where the client does like my work (which, of course, is what you want) and I'll look to capitalise on that, rather than feel annoyed or hard done by that I didn't get anywhere in a photo contest. The hard knocks will come and go, but it's churlish to take them personally. I don't like hard rock or techno, but I doubt the people making it care too much about that - they just keep doing what they're doing, because there is a market out there for what you do.
Saturday, 4 September 2010
Printing your Book...
Recently, I've become pretty obsessive when it comes to printing. Last month I submitted some shots for a portrait prize which unfortunately wasn't to be, but the whole experience reminded me of just how exacting I can be when it comes to getting everything perfect.
Since then, I've taken a fresh look at my portfolio 'book' and am making sure everything is as perfect as it possibly can be.
The first step I took was making sure my colour profile was spot on. In the past year, there have been disappointments when I've had some shots printed, only to find the final image is too dark, or the colours different from how I'd expected. It's very simple stuff, but it's something you can't treat lightly. If the shot you submit for a job or for a contest is all over the place in terms of colour and tonal depth, you're not going to get repeat business. Out of desperation and because it was the only one the shop I visited had (I was really desperate - normally I'd buy online), I went for the X-Rite EyeOne Display 2. The first time you use one you'll more than likely see a huge difference between your original monitor profile and the calibrated version - my own laptop monitor was much too 'cool' with the tonal range on screen being very blue. That translated into me compensating for that with shots that looked over-saturated and orange. My monitor was too bright too - so the fine shadow detail was lost in printing.
The next step was to get my book. When you go to a potential client, you want something that has impact, but isn't overcomplicated. I wanted something that was simple but showed I'd made an effort, so went for a Prat Pampa spiralbook in brown leather - simple, understated, and it allows my photos to do the talking. It has sleeves, which means I can add and remove photos depending on the job I'm going for. I just don't understand why some people go for the printed portfolios - your work can shift direction so quickly and if you can't show that in your book, what's the point? Ok, so the printed books are more polished, but as much as I tend to obsess about these things, sometimes that can be a little too much...
Finally, the shots themselves... I have to admit I haven't settled on an online printer yet - I used to use Peak Imaging simply by virtue of the fact that I'd always used them, but I don't trust their reproduction and their gloss prints aren't exactly outstanding. When it comes down to it, if you need to spend a little more to get the perfect reproduction then go for it - that print could be the difference between you getting a job or not. I've been very impressed by The Printspace, as they have a very clear range of papers and printing choices (including a YouTube video showing the different types), as well as a downloadable proofing profile to use in Photoshop for their different printing and paper types. Very impressive...
Of course, you can spend all the time in the world obsessing over the colours you're printing in and the quality and finish of your prints and the book, but at the end of the day, all that's nothing if you don't have the quality images - and the range of shots - to go in the book itself. Hence why I'm creating work and getting out there as much as I can to build up that portfolio. It's exhausting and expensive work, but has to be done...
Since then, I've taken a fresh look at my portfolio 'book' and am making sure everything is as perfect as it possibly can be.
The first step I took was making sure my colour profile was spot on. In the past year, there have been disappointments when I've had some shots printed, only to find the final image is too dark, or the colours different from how I'd expected. It's very simple stuff, but it's something you can't treat lightly. If the shot you submit for a job or for a contest is all over the place in terms of colour and tonal depth, you're not going to get repeat business. Out of desperation and because it was the only one the shop I visited had (I was really desperate - normally I'd buy online), I went for the X-Rite EyeOne Display 2. The first time you use one you'll more than likely see a huge difference between your original monitor profile and the calibrated version - my own laptop monitor was much too 'cool' with the tonal range on screen being very blue. That translated into me compensating for that with shots that looked over-saturated and orange. My monitor was too bright too - so the fine shadow detail was lost in printing.
The next step was to get my book. When you go to a potential client, you want something that has impact, but isn't overcomplicated. I wanted something that was simple but showed I'd made an effort, so went for a Prat Pampa spiralbook in brown leather - simple, understated, and it allows my photos to do the talking. It has sleeves, which means I can add and remove photos depending on the job I'm going for. I just don't understand why some people go for the printed portfolios - your work can shift direction so quickly and if you can't show that in your book, what's the point? Ok, so the printed books are more polished, but as much as I tend to obsess about these things, sometimes that can be a little too much...
Finally, the shots themselves... I have to admit I haven't settled on an online printer yet - I used to use Peak Imaging simply by virtue of the fact that I'd always used them, but I don't trust their reproduction and their gloss prints aren't exactly outstanding. When it comes down to it, if you need to spend a little more to get the perfect reproduction then go for it - that print could be the difference between you getting a job or not. I've been very impressed by The Printspace, as they have a very clear range of papers and printing choices (including a YouTube video showing the different types), as well as a downloadable proofing profile to use in Photoshop for their different printing and paper types. Very impressive...
Of course, you can spend all the time in the world obsessing over the colours you're printing in and the quality and finish of your prints and the book, but at the end of the day, all that's nothing if you don't have the quality images - and the range of shots - to go in the book itself. Hence why I'm creating work and getting out there as much as I can to build up that portfolio. It's exhausting and expensive work, but has to be done...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)