Tuesday, 21 September 2010

Porn as Art...?

I won't delude myself by thinking that anyone reads this, but this can be a useful place to put my thoughts into words...

At the moment, there seems to be a certain amount of debate over one of the finalists of the Taylor Wessing Photographic Portrait Prize that I mentioned in my last post. In short, one of the finalists is an uncompromising shot of the photographer's wife, who is naked from the waist down. Don't click the link if you're offended by images of women's genitalia, as it's a particularly graphic image.

Judging from the various reactions I've read, people are generally torn between admiration and disgust - as you'd probably expect. Some talk of an intimate beauty to the shot, while others say it's simply porn dressed up as art.

Where do I stand? Well, my feeling is more one of disappointment than of outright disgust. Some of the images from last year's prize were excellent, both technically and in terms of their subject matter and execution. Last year's winner, Paul Floyd-Blake's portrait of disabled swimmer Rosie Bancroft not only had great impact, but the shot was well lit, well composed, and you felt a connection with the subject.

While Panayiotis Lamprou hasn't won the prize (yet) with his 'Portrait of my British Wife', his inclusion in the shortlist sends out a very strong message - that the panel this year is more concerned with shock and provocation than with excellent portraiture.

I appreciate my opinion is meaningless in the grand scheme of things, but then this is my blog so I can say what I want. Overall, the image for me totally lacks any sort of impact - technically there's no depth to the shot, while the subject's expression speaks nothing of intimacy, and any emotion betrayed on her face is negated by the brashness - the brazenness - of her exposed genitals.

The question I ask is exactly what does the nudity bring to the shot? The pose appears unnatural - I can't think of any woman - any lady - who would display herself in such a manner - unless it's to shock or to provoke a reaction. The shot was set up - there's no doubt about that. I can't see any situation whereby a woman would sit in that way after "sharing an omelette" and I don't know who would have their camera on hand ready to snap that decisive 'moment'.

No - it's a poor photographer who resorts to the cheap trick of flashing his wife's vagina in order to give his shot impact, when there are countless photographers who allow their creativity, their imagination and their technique do the talking. All I see when I look at this shot is a conscious effort to shock, to provoke and to manipulate. The fact that the panel of judges has been taken in by this is a sad reflection on the state of our society today. I can't wait to hear how they're going to justify the inclusion of the shot on their shortlist.

Is it art? No - it's not even photography.

No comments:

Post a Comment