I saw a post on a Facebook page I've been following recently titled 'Does creativity come naturally? Or can it be learned?'
It's an age-old question, I know, and one that I'm sure has been debated countless times before, but this is my blog and I can write what I like - but thought I'd be a bit of a bitch along the way...
The trouble with any response to a question like this is the people responding. In my experience, and I may well end up counting myself in this group, since I'm arrogant enough to identify them, the people who respond to these questions tend to have an overly high opinion of their own abilities. They'll often post from their Facebook 'business' page, and if you follow the link to their page, or their website, you invariably end up on a site that shows very little of the creativity that they claim - in spades - to hold naturally.
My response to that question? You can't learn to be creative - not in photography - you just can't...
Certain aspects of photography can be picked up in no time - how to meter, the differences different shutter speeds make, controlling your depth of field using different apertures, understanding how shutter speed and aperture are intrinsically linked, white balance - the list goes on. Technically you can be the most proficient photographer, but does that mean you're creative? You can learn about composition, about thirds, about positioning, about talking to your subject if you have one, about arranging or setting up a scene, lighting your subject, but if you're being taught these things, at what point is it 'your' photography and not a reproduction of the technique you've been taught?
That's why I find it so hard to teach a person how to take a photo, because I feel there's a huge gap between helping someone learn their way around a camera and them taking photos - real photos... What they should be taught is how to make the image they might see in their head, or what they feel in their heart, a reality...
Let's put it musically - when I was young, I played the violin, and wasn't too bad either. When I spent time with other musicians, I frequently came across people who could play a piece of music absolutely note-perfect and in the perfect tempo. Their accenting was exactly the same as it appeared on the page of music - the crescendo, the legato, the grace notes - everything. As much as I admired their technical precision, it was the people who played the music that showed true emotion who impressed me. You see, anyone can learn to play 'Mary had a little lamb' given enough time, but if they don't have music in their soul, they'll never be able to do anything but a facsimile of what they've learnt.
The people who are responding to this post on the Facebook page saying that creativity can be learnt? I look at their photos and there's no soul - none of their own interpretation. It's just a record of a particular moment, with no specific art to it - apart from the crappy filter they applied using a Photoshop Elements plug-in they purloined from someone on Flickr or Picnic (or whatever it's called, however it's spelt...).
So the response is only as valuable as the person providing it - the response may be that 90% of the people posting say that creativity can be learnt, but if those 90% aren't truly creative, how representative a sample is that?
Showing posts with label Creativity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Creativity. Show all posts
Monday, 16 July 2012
Creativity...
Wednesday, 27 June 2012
The 'Others'...
By and large, I've never given much thought to other photographers and the work they're doing, because I'm doing my own work and it stands on its own merits. By and large though, my reason for feeling that way is because I don't tend to encounter that many other photographers - which means I don't have to confront my own insecurities about my abilities...
Today I visited somewhere I'll be doing some shoots in the coming weeks. It's a big job that I'm looking forward to - the location is fantastic and I know I'll meet some great people there. When I was being shown around though, I was introduced to another photographer, who was doing some work on-site. Nothing like what I was doing - just some staff portraits - but it stopped me in my tracks for a minute...
The staff portraits were good - they were lit with natural light, but what's noteworthy was that to get an even exposure, he was using a Lastolite reflector to bounce light back, so it hit both sides of the subject's face. So why did it stop me in my tracks...?
Whenever I'm on a job, I meet a lot of people who tell me their boyfriend/girlfriend/sister/friend is a photographer - a lot. Sometimes I'll ask for their details so I can look them up, but invariably (99 times out of 100) they're not making a living from photography, they just either have a half-decent camera, or they spend a lot of time uploading pictures to Flickr.
But no - in this case, the reflector showed that they'd thought things through - they'd thought about the light - they actually were a photographer...
My insecurity instantly makes me think - well this guy's clearly got a foot in the door - what's to say he doesn't get asked to do the photos I'm looking to do instead of me?
It was stupid I know... I don't know what this person's work is like, what their speciality is, even whether they're looking to do work like I'm doing. When it comes down to it as well, I know that I'm the one who came up with the idea for the work, and I have my own style and my own thoughts about the execution of the work...
At the end of the day, it's just a matter of insecurity and a lack of self-esteem - a trait I really don't mind admitting to. It comes with knowing that, while I have a very specific style, and I see light in a way that not so many fellow photographers seem to be able to, a lot of my work isn't down to a Photoshop technique that sets me apart from other people, or because my photos are processed in a way nobody else can - it's because of human relations - and to me, I don't know how much of that is something unique to me, or whether other people can get the same results - can someone who has, or is given, the same brief as me, end up with the same photos, or work that's better?
The insecurity I suppose comes from looking at my work pretty much all day, every day. It's become ordinary to me, and so I end up feeling like anyone can take the shots I can. In the end, I don't want to be the 'jobbing photographer' I've talked about in other posts - whose work just disappears into the background, doing the kind of work that's the equivalent of a session musician - something that could have been done by anyone, and only you know it's there. I guess the moral of the story is to push yourself, and to make sure you get the opportunities that the other people don't, but also to set yourself apart - in every aspect of your work - whether technique, approach or otherwise - to make sure you can always look at your work and feel proud of what you're doing.
Today I visited somewhere I'll be doing some shoots in the coming weeks. It's a big job that I'm looking forward to - the location is fantastic and I know I'll meet some great people there. When I was being shown around though, I was introduced to another photographer, who was doing some work on-site. Nothing like what I was doing - just some staff portraits - but it stopped me in my tracks for a minute...
The staff portraits were good - they were lit with natural light, but what's noteworthy was that to get an even exposure, he was using a Lastolite reflector to bounce light back, so it hit both sides of the subject's face. So why did it stop me in my tracks...?
Whenever I'm on a job, I meet a lot of people who tell me their boyfriend/girlfriend/sister/friend is a photographer - a lot. Sometimes I'll ask for their details so I can look them up, but invariably (99 times out of 100) they're not making a living from photography, they just either have a half-decent camera, or they spend a lot of time uploading pictures to Flickr.
But no - in this case, the reflector showed that they'd thought things through - they'd thought about the light - they actually were a photographer...
My insecurity instantly makes me think - well this guy's clearly got a foot in the door - what's to say he doesn't get asked to do the photos I'm looking to do instead of me?
It was stupid I know... I don't know what this person's work is like, what their speciality is, even whether they're looking to do work like I'm doing. When it comes down to it as well, I know that I'm the one who came up with the idea for the work, and I have my own style and my own thoughts about the execution of the work...
At the end of the day, it's just a matter of insecurity and a lack of self-esteem - a trait I really don't mind admitting to. It comes with knowing that, while I have a very specific style, and I see light in a way that not so many fellow photographers seem to be able to, a lot of my work isn't down to a Photoshop technique that sets me apart from other people, or because my photos are processed in a way nobody else can - it's because of human relations - and to me, I don't know how much of that is something unique to me, or whether other people can get the same results - can someone who has, or is given, the same brief as me, end up with the same photos, or work that's better?
The insecurity I suppose comes from looking at my work pretty much all day, every day. It's become ordinary to me, and so I end up feeling like anyone can take the shots I can. In the end, I don't want to be the 'jobbing photographer' I've talked about in other posts - whose work just disappears into the background, doing the kind of work that's the equivalent of a session musician - something that could have been done by anyone, and only you know it's there. I guess the moral of the story is to push yourself, and to make sure you get the opportunities that the other people don't, but also to set yourself apart - in every aspect of your work - whether technique, approach or otherwise - to make sure you can always look at your work and feel proud of what you're doing.
Labels:
Aspirations,
Cliché,
Client,
Commission,
Competition,
Confidence,
Creativity,
different,
Editorial,
Effort,
Fake Photographer,
fear,
Photographers,
Photoshop,
Self-Esteem,
Success,
Technique
Thursday, 14 June 2012
Recession...
Walking down the street today, I noticed that a shop that sells TVs and DVD players was offering a photocopying service. Maybe times are hard for that shop and they're not doing a lot of business - I didn't stop to ask - but it did make me think about the effect this 'recession' is having on people.
When I started out, the recession was just starting, and people said that I was crazy - that there's no work out there and I wouldn't survive. As I've said in other posts, it doesn't really matter how many thousands of photographers there are out there if you have something that sets you apart from those other people. When it comes down to it though, a profession doesn't just disappear because the global economy is having problems - I don't find myself walking down the street, tripping over the sleeping bodies of the homeless people unable to pay their bills, and for the most part, people are still working and they're still able to put food on the table.
People still need photos as well - the pages of a magazine don't fill themselves, and the websites and posters you see in your day to day life aren't devoid of images. People are still getting paid to take photos.
While I confess I haven't read the article, in my Twitter timeline today I saw the precis of an article that claimed that photography had made itself 'obsolete', and it kind of made me angry. What kind of world are we living in where the still image is having its obituary written? The defining images of our era are still images - they always have been and they always will be. Regardless of what people may say, the image I saw recently of President Obama walking up the steps of Air Force One wouldn't have more impact if it was a video - I wager that it would have had less impact. The images I'm taking for a commission at the moment wouldn't be more persuasive if they were videos of the subjects - the fact that they're moments in time actually leads you to ask more questions and the image has more meaning without words, moving images and a spoken narrative...
When Nikon released some new DSLRs, a person commented on the British Journal of Photography's Facebook page that it was the death knell of the professional photographer - since "now everyone will be able to take professional standard photos". I'd be worried if I felt so threatened by the release of a new camera. After all, our technology isn't what makes us - it's our eye and our passion. If all I had was a pinhole camera, I'd wager that I'd be able to take more impactful photos than Joe Bloggs with a Hasselblad H4D-200MS - or maybe those people are right - I take great photos and so must have a really good camera...
What I'm saying is that I don't think photography is dead - not by a long shot. I don't think photography is dying. I don't even think photography is unhealthy. I don't even think photography is having a bit of a sniffle. Photography is timeless and will always be. The world will be smothered in the snapshots taken by everyone and their so-called "professional standard cameras" but the people who make the images that really have impact will always stand apart.
Unlike the high street shop doing photocopies, I see no need to take on a sideline - I don't feel the need to go and work in a camera shop or do something similar in order to make ends meet, because as hard as times might be, I don't feel threatened by the market. Ask me in six months' time and maybe I'll have something different to say, but for the moment, I'm feeling good and looking forward to the future.
I suppose I'd better go and read that article now...
When I started out, the recession was just starting, and people said that I was crazy - that there's no work out there and I wouldn't survive. As I've said in other posts, it doesn't really matter how many thousands of photographers there are out there if you have something that sets you apart from those other people. When it comes down to it though, a profession doesn't just disappear because the global economy is having problems - I don't find myself walking down the street, tripping over the sleeping bodies of the homeless people unable to pay their bills, and for the most part, people are still working and they're still able to put food on the table.
People still need photos as well - the pages of a magazine don't fill themselves, and the websites and posters you see in your day to day life aren't devoid of images. People are still getting paid to take photos.
While I confess I haven't read the article, in my Twitter timeline today I saw the precis of an article that claimed that photography had made itself 'obsolete', and it kind of made me angry. What kind of world are we living in where the still image is having its obituary written? The defining images of our era are still images - they always have been and they always will be. Regardless of what people may say, the image I saw recently of President Obama walking up the steps of Air Force One wouldn't have more impact if it was a video - I wager that it would have had less impact. The images I'm taking for a commission at the moment wouldn't be more persuasive if they were videos of the subjects - the fact that they're moments in time actually leads you to ask more questions and the image has more meaning without words, moving images and a spoken narrative...
When Nikon released some new DSLRs, a person commented on the British Journal of Photography's Facebook page that it was the death knell of the professional photographer - since "now everyone will be able to take professional standard photos". I'd be worried if I felt so threatened by the release of a new camera. After all, our technology isn't what makes us - it's our eye and our passion. If all I had was a pinhole camera, I'd wager that I'd be able to take more impactful photos than Joe Bloggs with a Hasselblad H4D-200MS - or maybe those people are right - I take great photos and so must have a really good camera...
What I'm saying is that I don't think photography is dead - not by a long shot. I don't think photography is dying. I don't even think photography is unhealthy. I don't even think photography is having a bit of a sniffle. Photography is timeless and will always be. The world will be smothered in the snapshots taken by everyone and their so-called "professional standard cameras" but the people who make the images that really have impact will always stand apart.
Unlike the high street shop doing photocopies, I see no need to take on a sideline - I don't feel the need to go and work in a camera shop or do something similar in order to make ends meet, because as hard as times might be, I don't feel threatened by the market. Ask me in six months' time and maybe I'll have something different to say, but for the moment, I'm feeling good and looking forward to the future.
I suppose I'd better go and read that article now...
Thursday, 8 March 2012
A Flash of Inspiration...
While waiting to hear back about a couple of jobs, I've been going back to old shoots to revisit old shots to see if there was anything about them that I'd missed, or to see if I could make some improvements. In some cases I was simply pulling out the best shots so that I had something to send to the client to give them an idea of how the shoot went, so to have the opportunity to go back for a second look meant discovering some things I missed out on first time round.
A few days ago I did just that with some shots I took last November, and it brought to mind my post from a week or so ago - 'I See' - about using flash and being more creative with my lighting.
When I took the shot on the right, I initially didn't pay much attention to it when I was working with the shots in Lightroom and Photoshop later, as I had other shots of the subject where they were making eye contact with the camera and filled the frame better, that I thought worked better and just wanted to get them off to the client, but on closer inspection, something stood out here that I didn't notice before...
I actually lit this with one light - a very standard setup with the flash mounted camera left, maybe at 7 o'clock just to fill the subject's face with light, this being a very dark setting, and exposed for the ambient light in the background, as I wanted the pigs in the background to provide some context. Looking at it again, I noticed that there was a little bit of haze to the right of the subject's head, and a good bit of light that brought out the detail in her hair, adding that touch of extra 'glow' - not much, but enough... It's only a very slight difference from the other shots, but enough for me to notice it.
It turns out that for that one shot, the sun had come out, and in site of being in a covered barn, just enough light came in to create a natural 'hairlight'.
It's all part of the learning process, but it makes you think that much more carefully about how you're going to light your shots in future. At the time I took this, I didn't actually have another radio trigger so couldn't have backlit the subject, but it's something I know I'll think about in future - whether I can set up another flash behind my subject just to bring out some more detail. I have three radio triggers, so the possibilities are endless (well, the possibilities are threefold, but it doesn't sound as impressive - or as much fun...).
Bit of a pointless post maybe, but this blog is as much about my own learning experiences, and the fact that when it comes to lighting a subject in future, I won't hesitate to consider using a second light to bring the subject out from the background - it'll actually occur to me automatically now. Maybe it's not a huge step forward for the people that have been using strobes for a long time, but I remember this time a couple of years ago, I would never have considered using flash creatively - now it's something I'm confident in actively pursuing.
Small steps...
A few days ago I did just that with some shots I took last November, and it brought to mind my post from a week or so ago - 'I See' - about using flash and being more creative with my lighting.
When I took the shot on the right, I initially didn't pay much attention to it when I was working with the shots in Lightroom and Photoshop later, as I had other shots of the subject where they were making eye contact with the camera and filled the frame better, that I thought worked better and just wanted to get them off to the client, but on closer inspection, something stood out here that I didn't notice before...I actually lit this with one light - a very standard setup with the flash mounted camera left, maybe at 7 o'clock just to fill the subject's face with light, this being a very dark setting, and exposed for the ambient light in the background, as I wanted the pigs in the background to provide some context. Looking at it again, I noticed that there was a little bit of haze to the right of the subject's head, and a good bit of light that brought out the detail in her hair, adding that touch of extra 'glow' - not much, but enough... It's only a very slight difference from the other shots, but enough for me to notice it.
It turns out that for that one shot, the sun had come out, and in site of being in a covered barn, just enough light came in to create a natural 'hairlight'.
It's all part of the learning process, but it makes you think that much more carefully about how you're going to light your shots in future. At the time I took this, I didn't actually have another radio trigger so couldn't have backlit the subject, but it's something I know I'll think about in future - whether I can set up another flash behind my subject just to bring out some more detail. I have three radio triggers, so the possibilities are endless (well, the possibilities are threefold, but it doesn't sound as impressive - or as much fun...).
Bit of a pointless post maybe, but this blog is as much about my own learning experiences, and the fact that when it comes to lighting a subject in future, I won't hesitate to consider using a second light to bring the subject out from the background - it'll actually occur to me automatically now. Maybe it's not a huge step forward for the people that have been using strobes for a long time, but I remember this time a couple of years ago, I would never have considered using flash creatively - now it's something I'm confident in actively pursuing.
Small steps...
Labels:
Approach,
Atmosphere,
Backlight,
Creative,
Creativity,
Flash,
Hairlight,
Lighting,
Portrait,
Revisiting,
Setup,
Strobe,
Subject,
Sunlight,
Technique
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)