Monday, 16 July 2012

Creativity...

I saw a post on a Facebook page I've been following recently titled 'Does creativity come naturally? Or can it be learned?'

It's an age-old question, I know, and one that I'm sure has been debated countless times before, but this is my blog and I can write what I like - but thought I'd be a bit of a bitch along the way...

The trouble with any response to a question like this is the people responding. In my experience, and I may well end up counting myself in this group, since I'm arrogant enough to identify them, the people who respond to these questions tend to have an overly high opinion of their own abilities. They'll often post from their Facebook 'business' page, and if you follow the link to their page, or their website, you invariably end up on a site that shows very little of the creativity that they claim - in spades - to hold naturally.

My response to that question? You can't learn to be creative - not in photography - you just can't...

Certain aspects of photography can be picked up in no time - how to meter, the differences different shutter speeds make, controlling your depth of field using different apertures, understanding how shutter speed and aperture are intrinsically linked, white balance - the list goes on. Technically you can be the most proficient photographer, but does that mean you're creative? You can learn about composition, about thirds, about positioning, about talking to your subject if you have one, about arranging or setting up a scene, lighting your subject, but if you're being taught these things, at what point is it 'your' photography and not a reproduction of the technique you've been taught?

That's why I find it so hard to teach a person how to take a photo, because I feel there's a huge gap between helping someone learn their way around a camera and them taking photos - real photos... What they should be taught is how to make the image they might see in their head, or what they feel in their heart, a reality...

Let's put it musically - when I was young, I played the violin, and wasn't too bad either. When I spent time with other musicians, I frequently came across people who could play a piece of music absolutely note-perfect and in the perfect tempo. Their accenting was exactly the same as it appeared on the page of music - the crescendo, the legato, the grace notes - everything. As much as I admired their technical precision, it was the people who played the music that showed true emotion who impressed me. You see, anyone can learn to play 'Mary had a little lamb' given enough time, but if they don't have music in their soul, they'll never be able to do anything but a facsimile of what they've learnt.

The people who are responding to this post on the Facebook page saying that creativity can be learnt? I look at their photos and there's no soul - none of their own interpretation. It's just a record of a particular moment, with no specific art to it - apart from the crappy filter they applied using a Photoshop Elements plug-in they purloined from someone on Flickr or Picnic (or whatever it's called, however it's spelt...).

So the response is only as valuable as the person providing it - the response may be that 90% of the people posting say that creativity can be learnt, but if those 90% aren't truly creative, how representative a sample is that?

No comments:

Post a Comment