Showing posts with label HDR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label HDR. Show all posts

Monday, 21 May 2012

Expectation...

Around a month or so ago, I contacted a photographer whose work I'd seen on a photo agency's website to ask them about their work and just generally to make contact. You see so many photographers and so much work that it's rare to see something that appeals to you enough to want to get in touch. I was really happy then when the photographer in question responded and turned out to be a really nice, genuine person.

After some discussion, it turned out that having signed up to an agency, she was anxious about an unspoken expectation that she might have to change her style to keep up with the marketplace. It's true that all around us, we seem to be bombarded with images that are very polished and set up. A lot of photographers seem to be using the most elaborate lighting setups for what should - or perhaps more accurately could - be very simple and straightforward shots. You'll see people taking a very ordinary-looking portrait using three lights and wonder to yourself firstly "is that really necessary?" before moving on to the question "hang on - am I supposed to be doing things like this?"

It's easy to be carried along with the trends of the time - whether it's the HDR boom of five or so years ago, to the film-style Instagram look I seem to see all over Facebook these days. People always seem to be doing something different, and other photographers always seem to be adopting these new approaches before moving on to something new...

When it comes down to it though, these new styles and looks always end up feeling somewhat ubiquitous - when I see an Instagram filter on Facebook, I have no idea who took it - I only recognise the Instagram filter. Likewise when I see someone's using a tilt-shift filter on the iPhone, I can only see the effect, so overwhelmed is that photo by the filter.

When it comes down to it, it's all well and good to try new things, but the truth of it is that your style is your style. If you don't have a personal 'style' then Instagram is probably the place for you, with its filters and effects, but if you have your own style, why look to adopt a look that will render your photos the same as everyone else's?

The strength of my photos seems not to come from the overall 'look' - although that of course is something that I feel I do have to my shots - but the fact that I see to be able to get my subjects to open up to me - and that becomes the central focus of the shot - not the number of flashes I might have on a subject. The other day I was doing a shoot in a farm shop and saw the light streaming through the window and took the shot on the right. There were no flashes involved - no reflectors, no HDR, no tilt-shift - just me, the subject and my camera.

Shouldn't that be the way it should always be...?

Thursday, 8 December 2011

Too Much...?

I'm a photographer - so I see lots of photos. I seek them out, I look for inspiration, I deconstruct shots to see how they were done...

The deconstructing thing is a bit easier though when the photographer tells you how it was done - but all too often when I see how a shot was set up, I'm left asking whether it's overkill. It all seems so complex...

It's true - I tend to do shots that are either lit naturally, or use artificial light very sparingly. I'm more of a documentary photographer and tend to work with how things are than creating lighting that isn't actually there, but I do know how to use light - I've worked in studios and I've created my own lighting setups - so it's not like I just don't understand how things work.

The most I've ever used in one shot is two lights, with the potential for a bit of fill as well. In the shot here of Tom Sobey from Origin Coffee, I used two lights - my main light was a softbox behind the camera to the left, and I lit the roaster in the background using a silver umbrella behind some pallets in the midground of the shot to the right. The silver umbrella brought out the tones of the roaster.

It's true that I was going for a natural look with this, and I didn't want to use any more light because I wanted it to look like I was shooting using daylight. I think any more lights would have made this look artificial and unnatural - and that I think is my problem with some of the shots I see.

It used to be that you saved your elaborate light setups for studio work - normally for fashion shoots where you wanted your lighting to look artificial. I imagine what's happened over the years is that people have grown used to seeing these artificial setups and wanted to have that kind of look in all of their shots. Now you see it in wedding shoots, in everyday portraits - everywhere. People are layering their shots and using HDR-style techniques and they're actively creating that artificial look.

It does all seem like too much though. I saw a diagram recently of the setup for a very simple shot and the guy used five lights for it. Five...! There are people who'll use a couple of lights at least just to get a pure white background in a studio shot, ignoring the rest of the lights they'll be using on their subject.

In the end it does come down to style - just as I'll never use HDR in my shots, or that old chestnut, selective desaturation, I don't see myself using multiple light setups to create a completely artificial version of reality. I quite like the natural look after all, and the best light you can ever use is always the sun - even the people who use hundreds of lights will tell you that... Sometimes you feel when everyone else seems to be using elaborate lighting setups that you should be doing the same thing, but if it's just not your style, it's not your style.

While I've been writing this, I've thought about other situations where you use elaborate setups, and I thought about a cinema sound system. Some people go with a stereo system, while others have rear speakers, front speakers, a centre and a subwoofer and a full DTS cinema setup. That's not to say that the stereo setup is in any way 'inferior', just to my mind that it creates different results depending on what you want to achieve. The 5.1 setup creates more of a '3D' feel, but is that always what you want? I say no - but other people want something that blows you away every time.

Maybe I'm just more subtle...?

Saturday, 14 May 2011

Fashion...

There are fashions in every industry and every walk of life. I can remember when I worked in local government that there were initiatives that one organisation would pick up, and others would soon follow - it became embarrassing seeing the desperation of those who were "sharing good practice" but were in fact rehashing an approach that would inevitably become a cliché.

It's the same thing in photography of course - you'll see a certain kind of image that in a few weeks or months will be ubiquitous and later hackneyed. I remember when people first started discovering the things you could do in Photoshop, and we were suddenly swamped with images using selective desaturation - the red rose against a black and white background; there were the filters as well - posterise, stained glass, graphic... The list went on... Later, along came HDR and people went crazy for the 3D-like effect they could get

I was never a fan of effects like that - I felt that they were used in an attempt to turn a mediocre photo into something more, where the style outweighed the substance, and if you just scratched below that filter, you'd see that the image was ultimately dull and lifeless, with no specific strengths. I remember being called a snob though for not embracing this 'new technology' and preferring to add impact to my shots with framing, exposure, depth of field and - most importantly - content...

There are fashions in photojournalism as well - and I suppose that's a given. You see an image you like and you try to recreate that, but having seen images like the one above more and more, it kind of makes me wonder just what is driving this - because the continued use of this kind of image as a fallback just makes me feel that either photographers or picture editors are getting lazy.

Granted, it's an effective 'look' - it creates a human interest image that otherwise would be very difficult to achieve - you have the distraught parent or family member holding a picture of a relative, now dead, and the juxtaposition of the sadness and the apparent serenity of the subject of the photo is very powerful, but when you see it in the major newspapers at least a few times a week, it stars to lose that impact.

It sends me back to the times when I'd see people using (and over-using) those Photoshop techniques having seen another photographer's work and feeling like they were simply stealing that person's image - that person's idea, and that they weren't actually creating anything new themselves. It makes you question whether there are any truly new ideas out there, but at the end of the day you've got to ask ourself as well, are you so desperate that you have to bite on someone else's style to get published or paid?

NB: I have tried to find the name of the photographer who took the above image, but so far my search has proved fruitless. If you took it, or know who took it, please leave a comment and I'll be happy to credit or remove as appropriate.