Showing posts with label Lights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lights. Show all posts

Thursday, 8 December 2011

Too Much...?

I'm a photographer - so I see lots of photos. I seek them out, I look for inspiration, I deconstruct shots to see how they were done...

The deconstructing thing is a bit easier though when the photographer tells you how it was done - but all too often when I see how a shot was set up, I'm left asking whether it's overkill. It all seems so complex...

It's true - I tend to do shots that are either lit naturally, or use artificial light very sparingly. I'm more of a documentary photographer and tend to work with how things are than creating lighting that isn't actually there, but I do know how to use light - I've worked in studios and I've created my own lighting setups - so it's not like I just don't understand how things work.

The most I've ever used in one shot is two lights, with the potential for a bit of fill as well. In the shot here of Tom Sobey from Origin Coffee, I used two lights - my main light was a softbox behind the camera to the left, and I lit the roaster in the background using a silver umbrella behind some pallets in the midground of the shot to the right. The silver umbrella brought out the tones of the roaster.

It's true that I was going for a natural look with this, and I didn't want to use any more light because I wanted it to look like I was shooting using daylight. I think any more lights would have made this look artificial and unnatural - and that I think is my problem with some of the shots I see.

It used to be that you saved your elaborate light setups for studio work - normally for fashion shoots where you wanted your lighting to look artificial. I imagine what's happened over the years is that people have grown used to seeing these artificial setups and wanted to have that kind of look in all of their shots. Now you see it in wedding shoots, in everyday portraits - everywhere. People are layering their shots and using HDR-style techniques and they're actively creating that artificial look.

It does all seem like too much though. I saw a diagram recently of the setup for a very simple shot and the guy used five lights for it. Five...! There are people who'll use a couple of lights at least just to get a pure white background in a studio shot, ignoring the rest of the lights they'll be using on their subject.

In the end it does come down to style - just as I'll never use HDR in my shots, or that old chestnut, selective desaturation, I don't see myself using multiple light setups to create a completely artificial version of reality. I quite like the natural look after all, and the best light you can ever use is always the sun - even the people who use hundreds of lights will tell you that... Sometimes you feel when everyone else seems to be using elaborate lighting setups that you should be doing the same thing, but if it's just not your style, it's not your style.

While I've been writing this, I've thought about other situations where you use elaborate setups, and I thought about a cinema sound system. Some people go with a stereo system, while others have rear speakers, front speakers, a centre and a subwoofer and a full DTS cinema setup. That's not to say that the stereo setup is in any way 'inferior', just to my mind that it creates different results depending on what you want to achieve. The 5.1 setup creates more of a '3D' feel, but is that always what you want? I say no - but other people want something that blows you away every time.

Maybe I'm just more subtle...?

Friday, 25 November 2011

Rethinking Video...

For a long time, I've been the kind of photographer who's been suspicious of the way camera manufacturers seem to be pushing professional stills photographers towards cameras that have video capabilities. Over the past few years, there's been a massive increase in the number of DSLRs and even smaller compacts that have HD video capabilities - and while I've sometimes been tempted to pick up a video camera and see what results I ended up with, I've always been fairly firm in the idea that photographers do what they do, and video people do what they do - they're different skill sets and you either don't mix them up, or you do one and not the other.

That was my thinking, and I didn't believe that was going to change - after all, I always felt I was good at taking stills because that was just how I framed the world, and that if I moved into filming, I'd be terrible at it because to me it would represent a continuous 'framing' that would just get steadily more complicated. One frame is fine, but 24 frames per second...? It didn't add up, probably because I was looking at things in the wrong way.

It all sounded crazy - and impossible. I had some favourite cinematographers and to me their work was beautiful but ultimately out of the question. I could sit and watch something like 'Lost in Translation' a hundred times over for the cinematography alone, but to create something like that myself? No way...

At the start of the year, I was the stills photographer for a shoot for a TV commercial, and while I was incredibly fortunate to have that opportunity, it didn't really change my thoughts on my place in the industry, and to be honest, the people on set who I spoke to saw things in much the same way. They didn't try to be photographers, so why should I believe I can come and do what they do? Specialist skills for specialist circumstances - and that's the way it is.

Ok, so maybe that's not exactly how it is. Remember I was talking to these people at a time when the big DSLR companies were bringing out cameras with HD video capabilities, and there were photographers who had shot entire films using a Canon EOS 5D - and ended up with results that were in some cases just as effective as the ones they were doing with their Arri cameras. They were also feeling like their market was being encroached upon and were rightly protective of it - imagine how you'd feel if all of a sudden you had a bunch of photographers acting like they could do what you've been doing for years, as if it was something easy. Much the same I'm sure, when a bunch of people who had taken a few pretty shots with their bridge camera at a friend's wedding decided that they were going to become a photographer...

I digress...

That experience made me feel like video definitely wasn't the way I wanted to go, but as I've moved forward with my own career and changed the way I work, it's actually become a lot clearer to me how things do work, and how video - while never going to be a speciality - could be something I can do as something that will create a bit of extra work here and there - and a conversation with a good friend has only served to engrain that thinking further.

He's been shooting video for years now, and told me that in many ways, being a photographer means you're more likely to take more care over the setup of the shoot, which means you're in a much more creative position when it comes to using lighting, because you're looking at things in the same way as you would light a single shot in photography, but that lighting is simply a stage for a longer shot.

The thing about photography is that when you're on a shoot you never just take one photo and leave it at that. For some shoots you have to take a variety of images because you have to have a selection of shots for the client, while at other times you're just trying out different things until you get the shot you want.

Film feels similar in the sense that you set up your shot - whether it's your lighting or your angle - and then you run through a scene. If it works, you have a few more takes just to make sure everything's perfect, and then you move on to the next setup, and do the same thing there.

It's been an eye-opener, because it's changed the way I see the whole process - whereas beforehand I felt that you had to consider so many different things, you're really only thinking about a couple of key points - and these are more or less the same ones you're considering when you're shooting stills - lighting, angle and subject. Would I go out and tout for video work? I don't think so, but if I'm asked to shoot some video as part of a stills job? Maybe...

The way I look at it is as a learning experience. Six years ago I'd never picked up a flash in my life, and now they're an integral part of the majority of my shoots - I certainly don't avoid them like I used to anyway. It was the same with studio work and studio lighting - a few years ago I didn't have a clue, but now I have wireless triggers, softboxes, umbrellas and snoots, and a collection of stands and A-clamps for holding it all together. Why should film be any different?

Now I just have to wait for a job to come up where that might happen, but I'm certainly not going to shy away from it...

Editing though... Now that terrifies me...