Showing posts with label CS2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CS2. Show all posts

Sunday, 8 April 2012

The (Colour) Space Between Us...

The title's just the name of one of my favourite Zero 7 songs - nothing to do with the post, but I thought it was a little clever - check me out...

I mentioned in an earlier post that I'd decided to pick up a copy of Photoshop for the Mac, as opposed to working with my decrepit copy of CS2 on my PC. A look at my book last week encouraged me to take a fresh look at my colour management though, as there seemed to be some issues.

I get most of my work printed at theprintspace. They're friendly, do a very quick turnaround and include lots of helpful information on their website on colour profiling - fantastic if, like me, you want to make sure your prints are as close to what you see in your mind's eye as is possible.

Just recently though I've had a few images through that had either a bit of a cyan or magenta cast to them, and was wondering where this was coming from. I was working on my PC using a monitor calibrated with an i1 Display and I'd downloaded their ICC profiles to ensure my working colour profile was as close to their printers as possible. It just didn't make sense. I decided to check out the images I'd had printed on my Mac to see if there was a difference in the profiles.

I was actually pretty surprised...

Have a look at the image on the right - it's my Mac on the left and my PC on the right. Both in Adobe RGB. The Mac is running Photoshop CS5 and the PC is running CS2, but they've been calibrated using the same calibration tool a matter of days apart. The image on the PC looks much more natural, because that's basically how I wanted the shot to look when I edited it on the PC, but the image on the Mac screen is exactly the same image, just open on a different machine.

It's pretty scary...

The image on the Mac looks like it has a cyan/green cast to it - and it does. You could be mistaken for thinking that the Mac's the machine that's not calibrated properly, but given the images I'm getting back from the printer, it's actually the one that's most accurate. The PC screen, though you can't really see it here, has more of a yellow cast to it, making the shots look much warmer, but put them on another monitor and they look very different. As I've essentially been overcompensating for a particular colour cast, I've actually ended up introducing another with my corrections.

Print them out and the shots aren't too offensive - it's just you end up with a cyan cast and a much cooler image, but that doesn't suit a shot where my subject is pouring bright yellow lemon curd into jars - it's supposed to look warm, and the print image just doesn't look that way - it actually looks cold...

I decided to give it another go - like I've done with other shots that I've revisited to see if I can bring them out more, I gave this shot another go, now with Photoshop CS5 on what seems to be a better calibrated monitor, and ended up with this on the left... It feels much more natural to me - and much warmer too. It was edited using theprintspace's ICC profile for Fuji Gloss, and while it could do with a little more work (there's a little bit of a green cast, and I'd like to bring the reds down a little) it's nowhere near as 'cool' as the previous version.

Oh - and open the images by clicking on them. For some reason the smaller thumbnails render differently from how they look when they're open - the first image looks more red, while the other actually looks quite neutral. Open the second and you'll see that the second image looks almost drained of colour.

It's annoying when things like this happen - as far as I'm concerned if you calibrate your monitor using the same device, both monitors should look exactly the same, but this is clearly not the case here.

So it's difficult to know exactly what you're going to end up with - I was sat there at my PC thinking that I was editing an image that would be perfect when printed, but loading it on a different computer using a different monitor, you can see just how much difference there can be. Maybe when it comes down to it, I'm being too picky about things, but then, why spend the time setting up a shot and taking the image, before mastering it in Photoshop afterwards, only to find when it comes to printing that your colour profiles are completely off?

It's crazy - it's not something you can just convert to the new profile on your other computer - you have to start from scratch with the original RAW image. Best to get it right from the start than to have to go back time and time again, while spending a fortune paying for prints that don't look right...