Showing posts with label Contrast. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Contrast. Show all posts

Sunday, 26 August 2012

The Devil is in the Detail...

It's been a while since I attached a picture to one of my posts, and I know how dull it can sometimes seem when all I do is talk. What better way to bring an image into a post then, than to talk about printing images...?

I've got (to me) a fairly big meeting coming up, that may well bring in some higher profile work. As a result of that, I'm going to need my book to be as up to date as possible, and so I'm having a look through my recent work to see what I feel makes me stand out. A cursory glance through my portfolio book as it is - last updated about six months ago - and I can see there's a lot that's gone on in that time.

With that in mind though, this means a lot of printing, and my printer of choice, as good as they are, costs a lot of money for an A4 print. As my portfolio is changing a lot, I wanted to see what sort of results I could get from my cheap as chips Epson printer. I was surprised at the results - for both good and bad reasons...

I should probably have started out with a 'control' image - something I'd had printed professionally and had a good result - but most of those files I've archived, and so they're not always to hand. I started out with an outtake from a recent editorial shoot...

The image on the monitor is probably too small for comparison, and as such, you can't see all of the fine detail, but what was clear to me from the outset was that it didn't have the contrast that I had in the original file. When you take it away from the screen and come back to it after a while, having forgotten how I originally planned on it looking, it looks like a perfectly respectable image - especially when it's backlit - but when it comes down to it, it isn't what I wanted - the light coming in from camera right isn't bright enough, while the darker tones actually have a cyan cast to them, rather than being outright black. I was actually pretty surprised by that.

I could probably put that shot in my book and it would be a perfectly respectable shot, as I say, but when you want to show off your best work, surely the idea is to have an image that's exactly as you'd intended it...?

So for the next print, I decided to go with a side by side comparison. I should say first off that this isn't perfect - when I first printed this, I was using my PC, which in spite of having used my colour calibrator on it, it turned out that the calibration was off, as some of you might have seen in an earlier post - 'The (Colour) Space Between Us' where it turned out that there's colour calibration and then, well, there isn't... I did a few tweaks of some of the images I'd printed using the PC's colour profile and saved the Mac-calibrated version for later printing. For reference, the print in the top right of the shot was also printed at the same time, and it had a heavy magenta cast, as you should probably be able to see...

The difference is pretty shocking isn't it...? The image on the left is the professionally printed one, and the one on the right is the adjusted-yet-home-printed one. In the end, the changes I made on the Mac between the first time this was printed and the home-printed version have come through quite strongly - it's lighter and there's less detail lost in the dark contrast, but can you see how blue the blacks look? It seems that when you print off a letter, the blacks you see on the page are fine, but when you try to print anything resembling something photo-quality, it's definitely blue... As before though, separate the two out and you've got a perfectly respectable image, but it's not what I'm looking for.

I should have taken a shot of the home-printed one next to the laptop for what the target image should have been...

But the positive side? The printer cost next to nothing - I only bought it for printing invoices and letters - so to get anything resembling photo-quality results out of it is fantastic. Now if someone wants an A5 image, or I decide I want to print something for the home, they'll do fine. It's nice to know I've got the option.

When it comes to my portfolio though, you really have to go down the no expense spared route. It's a pain in the arse printing every couple of months, as it's expensive and you end up discarding a lot of shots as your portfolio grows, but it's an investment at the same time, and you simply can't afford to scrimp. The picture editors, creative directors and potential clients don't want to hear an excuse about how your home printer has a cyan cast in place of deep blacks - they want to see - deserve to see - what your best work actually looks like...

Monday, 28 November 2011

On the Bright Side...

My photos are darker than most. It's intentional... You'll rarely catch me taking a shot that's bright and breezy, or full of natural bright light... I don't always know why that is - it just seems that I'm drawn to shadow, and I love contrast...

I do sometimes wonder if that's what puts people off sometimes though - my work has been referred to at times as 'moody' or 'atmospheric', and granted, these have been for theatre jobs where the production has been dark and moody, but then I do get the feeling that the whole 'moody' thing was a diplomatic way of saying my shots are too dark.

On Saturday I put in an order for another batch of business cards from moo.com, and the diplomacy came up again when it came to uploading shots to go on the reverse side of the cards...


What you're looking at above is a screengrab from the image upload page. You basically upload your shots so you can preview them before ordering. What moo do though, is automatically (politely...?) optimise your images so - by their standards - they're being presented in the best light. It can be annoying - especially when as a photographer you feel the shots you're uploading are as they're supposed to be, and it's especially frustrating when you're uploading your shots to an actual printing website - I understand that some people don't have Photoshop or Lightroom, and so they don't have the tools to adjust their images, but at the same time, I don't generally appreciate having my images adjusted for me.

You can switch it off, as I did, but it has made me ask the question of whether my images, while dark, are too dark...

When printed, my shots pretty much always look how I want them to look - the contrast, the tones, the colours... After all, I didn't spend a fortune on getting a colour profiler if I didn't want to be as certain as I could be that the images on my screen were as close to what was going to be printed, or what I wanted to appear on my portfolio.

For reference, the original version of the image you see above is here on the right - and you can see that it is much darker - there are more shadows and there's more contrast. I actually like that, but is it what the client wants? Looking at it, I still prefer my version - I feel there's more depth to it, and it's not at the expense of the detail either. You can see the subject's face and eyes, and you can make out everything in the shot - you're not left straining to work out what you're looking at. The whites are white, not grey, and the background doesn't intrude into the shot.

It's not difficult to end up with the shot above - I always underexpose by one stop, so I have some exposure latitude to work with. By removing that, and not using contrast in Photoshop when it comes to the editing of the image, I would have an image as bright as the one you see above - but then looking at it, would it be a shot you can identify as being one of my shots, or would it be just another shot, like any other you might see in a magazine or newspaper...?

I'd love to know what anyone else thinks...

Monday, 21 November 2011

The Enigma...

Image Credit: The Philips Collection/Pierre-Auguste Renoir
One of my favourite films is 'Le Fabuleux Destin d'Amélie Poulain' and when I was working on an image recently, I felt a certain affinity with the character Raymond Dufayel - the 'Glass Man' - who spends his days copying Renoir's 'Luncheon of the Boating Party'. The way the story goes, he feels he is never truly able to capture the woman sipping from the glass adequately, as her mood changes all of the time, thus frustrating him.

There's one shot of mine that no matter how much I work on it, I never seem to be able to get it right or do it justice. You'll probably recognise it straight away, and it's frustrated me so much that I've actually removed it from my website. It's the shot of the butcher holding the string of sausages in the back room of their shop. I'm going to use this post to try and break the editing process down into its constituent parts in the hope that maybe, just maybe, breaking it down like this can help me make sense of where I'm going wrong.

No matter what I do to it, it never seems to be 'just right'. Granted, as I've mentioned in a previous post, since I picked up the D700, I've felt the need to revisit old images as the better processing engine of the camera shows many of the failings of the D200, but there's this something about this image in particular that never seems to work.

As it stands, it's very much a 'me' shot - there's an industrial feel from the stainless steel of the butcher's back room, as well as the pose, the expression and the overall 'feel' of the shot, but it's when I get it into post-processing that I tend to lose something - I tend to over-do things...

On the right here is the 'raw' image - straight out of camera. When I shot this originally, I was trying to find a middle ground by balancing the white balance between the natural light that was coming in from the front of the shop and the fluorescent lighting in the back room. Because of this, there's a strong blue/green colour cast that I need to tone down a little.

So if we correct the colour balance in Photoshop, I've moved the blue slider down to -20, the green to -5 and the red to +10. This seems quite drastic, but looking at the image on the colour-calibrated monitor in AdobeRGB format, the whites look more natural while the overall look and feel of the shot is a lot more balanced. Looking at the preview on the blog, it does look like the reds area little too saturated, but trust me - in Photoshop it does look more natural!

Next up, I sharpen the image and adjust the contrast after sharpening. I tend to find that when I sharpen my shots, it does tend to make the blacks a lot darker, and so I bring up the midtones a little until things look more natural. I've never liked excessive saturation in my images, and so I bring the saturation down slightly (and this also reduces the blue cast you can see behind the subject in the front of the shop). One of the things I've found when I've edited this image in the past is that I've gotten carried away with the sharpening and the contrast, to the point the subject looks false, and the sharpening has been pushed much too far. That may have looked ok from an extreme processing point of view (it did look kind of HDR/high key) but then that's not 'me' and it's also not what I was looking to do with the project I was doing - after all, if one shot is high key in a series of portraits where the lighting and toning is natural and sympathetic, it's just going to look odd...

So then, the final image... We're left with something that has much less of a blue cast to it, with the green dialed down as well, it's been sharpened, but not overly so. Am I happy with this image? I think so. It's been useful to break down the steps in the editing process here, as it's made me think that much more carefully about what I'm doing but also why. If I could go back and shoot this again, maybe I'd move the white bucket out of the way - even though it's where the sausage casings are kept - and I might be tempted to set up a small fill flash on the left of the shot, as it would increase the toning a little, and it would also give me a natural looking catchlight in the subject's eyes - at the moment they're a little dark, and dodging would both be a little dishonest, as well as leading to a look that wouldn't look as natural as if I'd used a strobe. But then, who's to say the subject would have been happy to wait around while I set up a light stand and fired off a few test shots to make sure I had my levels right?


I've taken better shots, granted, but I'm now a little more confident in uploading this to the website as a part of this project - I think I was just too swayed by other shots I'd seen and was trying to make this something it wasn't. Now let's just move this to the file marked 'finished' and forget about it...

...for a few weeks...

UPDATE: You won't believe it but I've come back to it already. I hadn't paid much attention to the colour channel mixer in Lightroom, but it gives you much more options in terms of toning down the saturation for individual colours - something that's less straightforward in Photoshop. I've now toned down the blue channel - which means that the background, which was interfering with the overall colour balance, is now much less intrusive... Have I finished with this shot? I certainly hope so... I must look such an amateur...