Showing posts with label Protest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Protest. Show all posts

Tuesday, 21 June 2011

A Question of Ethics...?

People who have followed my work for a while will know that in early 2010 I started a project on political dissent and activism. The idea was that when I was at university doing my politics degree, and later my MSc, I became obsessed with the political activism I was hearing about - like the Battle of Seattle, and reading about in books like Naomi Klein's 'No Logo'. I was also working at the Body Shop, and believe it or not, that gave me a much greater exposure to the idea of community and fair trade, and the idea of ethics in purchasing and consumption.

On leaving university, I found that the world wasn't this hotbed of activism and dissent I thought it would be, and in fact found it to be quite tame. Put simply, people seemed to care more about EastEnders and shopping than the state of global politics. I wanted to see what activism and dissent looked like in the modern world, and whether it still existed, or if it had just taken a different form from what I thought it looked like.

And in a roundabout way, that's how I met Brian Haw...

I was living in London at the time, and getting to meet him was a simple matter of heading down to Parliament Square, where his protest was based, rocking up and having a chat. I went to visit him quite a few times to build up a rapport for the eventual shots I was going to be taking of him, as well as to collect soundbites from him on the nature of his protest and why he was doing it. One of my favourite shots was the result...

I was understandably affected when I heard of his death over the weekend, of lung cancer.

I put a link to the news story of his death on my personal Facebook page, and shortly after, I received some suggestions that I should get in touch with some newspapers and offer them my photos. This put me in an interesting position...

We've seen from my last post that there are many photographers who 'make money' from death, in the sense that their shots show death and destruction in all its forms and they earn their living from shooting this. This is all very different from an editorial photographer having some shots of a person who's just died hanging around in their portfolio. It just seemed a little cynical that I might be looking to earn some money in that way...

Let's look at it this way though - if I'd licensed the photo to an image library and the shot been used by them, that image library would make a profit from the photo. The images that have been used in his obituaries across various newspapers and magazines have all received a fee as well. Image usage fees don't change simply because the person in question happens to be dead - and I happen to have an image that has the potential to be used.

I suppose in some ways I need to toughen up and think about these things less, because as time goes on the likelihood is that I'll take another photo one day that might highlight a person's suffering, or perhaps show them in a light that isn't completely dignified. The main thing I suppose is not to lose my moral compass, to become cynical and to start taking photos because of their capacity to shock or because they're distasteful. The aim is to raise awareness, and whether that shot is of a person smiling, a person suffering or a person dying, if I can get that shot out there and educate or inform, then my job's done - the money doesn't come into it...