From the introduction to 'Lowlife' by Scot Sothern, 1986"In my eyes they could see my craving for the nasty little secret I kept from friends and family. I could give my twenty dollars to any one of these women. I could buy a quick sex fix and she could buy enough crack to put a smile on her face for an hour or so.In the passenger seat, belted and buckled, frail and beautiful, my four-year-old son, Dashiell, slept curled around his best friend, a pillow-sized stuffed facsimile of Hulk Hogan. It was Sunday night and my weekend with my little boy was over."
In recent months, I've had to ask myself what I'd put myself through for my photography - to tell a story... While I want my photography to portray the positive things in life, I also want to show the flipside, and for every positive project I want to raise awareness of the trials of life, and the fact that there are plenty of people out there on the social fringes who struggle just to get through the day. Some of the projects I'm wanting to do in the future involve some distressing subjects - objectification, drug use, poverty...
Reading about the experiences of some photographers can be a harrowing experience - war photographer Don McCullin has seen the kinds of things that would keep anyone awake at night, while Pulitzer Prize-winning photographer Kevin Carter ostensibly committed suicide because of the things he'd seen during the apartheid era.
The way I am now, I think I'm too much of a coward to willingly and knowingly put myself into any genuinely dangerous situations - I'm not about to jump on a plane to cover the wars in Iraq or Afghanistan - but it's entirely possible that by simply going about my business I might end up in a situation where I am at risk.
There's also the possibility of seeing some rather distasteful things as well - things that once seen, can't be unseen... So if I want to raise awareness of what I see to be the damage that porn does to women and men, or the suffering of people addicted to heroin, how can I complete those projects without seeing things that might be damaging or upsetting...? You can't make a difference without showing people how things really are, but then if I'm not willing to put myself in those situations how can I tell their stories...?
My citing Scot Sothern is a different matter though. I read about his book, which details ten years of photographing prostitutes in Southern California in the 1980s, in the BJP today. To me, this would be an insight into the world of prostitution and to raise awareness of the experiences of women who work in the sex trade, but he clearly didn't see it that way - no, he makes it clear that he slept with many of these women, and writes about his experiences in a pornographic style...
"This babe is gorgeous. I spend way beyond my budget and would give her more if I had it... I insert my dick and with my hands on either side of her, push myself up like a push-up so that I can look at her body, as well as my dick as it goes in and out. She shivers as though she really likes it and maybe she really does."The reviews of Sothern's work I've read praise his uncompromising approach - about how he bravely goes beyond voyeurism and apparently "renders his subjects with dignity and compassion". Having seen some of the images, I see no dignity, and I can see no compassion from a man who clearly, after paying the prostitutes for their time, sees no reason why he shouldn't get his money's worth. A story is told of how a former subject who has since gone straight as an actor, asks him to destroy the images - he promises he'll obscure her face, but doesn't - only obscuring her eyes so the rest of her is plainly obvious. How is she afforded dignity by not protecting her identity so that she might have a chance to escape this cruel trade?
Sothern's photobook retails for £25 in the UK - and I don't doubt that many will buy it and rave about his uncompromising approach. I'm sure he'll make a fair bit of money from it too.
When I was doing my Master's degree, I did a course on social research, and as you'd expect, the course covered ethics. You don't need to be a genius to work out that sleeping with your subjects - people who are already in an incredibly vulnerable situation - is highly unethical. It brings nothing to the photography and brings no additional insight to the life of a sex worker. I don't know Scot Sothern but his approach and his comments make it clear he had no interest in the wellbeing of his subjects, nor has he any qualms about breaking all the ethical rules...
Put simply, this project is about a man documenting his experiences with prostitutes - and is such a wasted opportunity...