Sunday, 12 May 2013

Are we still having *that* conversation...?

As always, busy month. So much for posting a couple of times a week... Hopefully people reading are more pleased that I'm busy than annoyed I'm not posting, but then who reads this anyway...?

Straight into it then...

I saw a tweet a couple of days ago where someone had done some work for a magazine where they'd insisted that they work with film. This wasn't a small publication - it was a national publication.

It got me wondering why they went down that line. It's the kind of thing I don't know without speaking to the picture editor, but it does make me wonder, as someone who has shot using digital for a good few years now, what that means for me, as someone who genuinely wants to work with that particular publication. It's not difficult for me to get hold of a film camera through eBay - I mean, I have a Kodak Vecta box camera my aunt and uncle gave me for Christmas as well if it came to that - but I'm just wondering about the thought process involved there that compels the editor to require a shoot is carried out using film.

I'm old enough that I started out when film was still the dominant format. My first 'proper' camera was a Minolta X-700 with a great selection of MD lenses. I know how to use a film camera, and I know the effort it takes to make sure you get a shot right first time. I still use that approach in my photography today - why wouldn't I? I'm not the kind of person who fires away, wasting hundreds of frames, and I'm also not the kind of person who sits there 'chimping' after every shot to check to make sure I've got my exposure right, or to make sure the white balance is ok. That makes me a little old-fashioned in some people's books - who to me are part photographer and part graphic designer and retoucher - and it took me a long time to understand that there was nothing necessarily wrong with my approach to photography, just that it was different - and I relied more on my ability to work with people than looking at a shot and seeing the post-processing possibilities.

The look of the shot though? I can understand when people say that film has a particular quality, but I've always thought that if someone was going to hire you, they'd hire you for the complete package? If your work has a particular look to it, that's a look that in some way is dependent on the format you shoot in - that's the look you were hired for. Surely then requiring someone to shoot in a particular format kind of defeats that object... Say for example, someone has achieved great success only using their iPhone - handing them a Hasselblad or even a standard SLR might completely change the way that person works. Adaptability is one thing, but it might also be a goose/golden egg scenario.

All that aside, it comes down to me being a little bit selfish and a little bit nervous - I don't want to miss out on work because I shoot digital, and I don't want to be categorised as a 'digital' photographer, when as far as I'm concerned I'm just a photographer - but I don't want to have to go to a lot of extra effort and expense to prove that, when my work should stand on its own merits...

No comments:

Post a Comment