Wednesday, 19 October 2011

Style Dilemna...

No, you haven't stumbled upon a fashion blog by mistake...

Today, I was editing some photos from a shoot I did yesterday, and realised that for a number of shots, my editing was moving towards how I thought other people would want them to look, as opposed to being true to myself and producing shots the way I wanted them to be.

It's something that's happened to me a few times - and in all honesty I've never been entirely sure what to do...

The issue for me is that often when I've been doing some personal work, or a freebie to boost my portfolio, I've ended up taking the kinds of shots that I think have more commercial appeal to them - where the lighting is even and unoffensive, the subject (if there is one) is adopting a pretty standard pose, and the colouring is straightforward with no surprises.

Looking back on this though, I kind of feel this is wrong...

I may have mentioned on a past entry that I had a chat with a magazine picture editor who appraised my portfolio and ended up telling me that my best work was my personal work. This was good for my confidence, since my portfolio isn't actually broken up into 'paid' work and 'personal' work - there's a mixture of the two. It was good because even though this person didn't know they were looking at some of my personal work, they saw it and thought it was strongest, and had the best commercial application.

Great - the shots I take for fun are the ones that people like the most - but not only that, they're the ones that magazine picture editors are more likely to use.

So why did I fall back into that trap recently...?

My problem is that your average person doesn't tend to like my style of photography. That might sound weird, but when you think about it, the average person likes evenly exposed pictures of babies, children, animals and landscapes. I saw a programme on TV a couple of months ago where there was a photo contest ('send your photos in, you vote on the best, and oh, by the way, you surrender the copyright to your photos when you upload them...') and the photos people voted for were the colourful ones, the ones that were factual rather than interpretative, and had little really going for them in terms of 'style'... Your average person is not a consumer of shadows, of toning, of different angles, or approaches that think outside of the box. Those things are more the kinds of things a photographer would appreciate.

This is the problem I've had though - the dilemna. I'm doing a personal project that may well result in a commercial application - so I've got to take shots that show a certain element of my style, but which could end up being used in a commercial application, and so have to have that commercial slant to them. At the same time though, if the project goes nowhere, I want to have something to show for my time for the portfolio. Of course, the other point I have to remember is that I'm working with the subjects of these shots and have to provide them with something at the end of the day that they can use for their own purposes - website, catalogue, family Christmas card - and I have to make sure I have shots that they like, otherwise I'm not going to have continued support for the project - and that's the issue - the people you're approaching about these kinds of projects tend to have more traditional tastes, or they recognise that their customers want to see straightforward shots that aren't too out of the ordinary...

As a result, I've taken a selection of images - the same as I'd do on any paid job - get the shots that you think are more likely to be used, before taking some that you either think definitely won't be used, but'll look good in the portfolio, or that might make the picture editor think twice - the ones that show off more of your style and your insight, that might just surprise you when you see them being used...

The moral of the story is that I have to remember to take shots that are a more commercial representation of my style - as opposed to shots that are simply commercial, with a few of my own stylistic elements thrown in. Take the shot above for example - it's something that highlights the fact that I like a bit of shadow in my shots for some mood (a recent client called it "atmospheric", but I think what they meant was that it was darker than what they wanted) and the fact that I love my shots to have some kind of 'context' to them that tells you something about the subject, but it also has that touch of 'Observer Food Monthly' about it too, in terms of the framing, the crop, and the positioning of the subject.

I think it works well, but I've got a few other angles and exposures to choose from if this is a little too much, or if they want a portrait format shot, but when it comes down to it, there are undeniable elements here that to me, mark it out as a shot that I've taken as opposed to something anyone can take, but it doesn't lose too much of the commercial element either.

I'd love to know what you think - too much or too little of my style? How would you feel if you saw it in a magazine or newspaper? It all helps...

No comments:

Post a Comment